The Right Hook Collision

This case determines the liability for a right hook collision involving a vehicle and a cyclist at the intersection of Hollywood Road South and Highway 33 in Kelowna.

The Cyclist

Valerie Charlton-Miner was riding northbound in the Hollywood Road cycle lane approaching Highway 33 and intended to travel straight through the intersection. The traffic light was green but turned to yellow as she entered the intersection. Realizing that it was turning right, she braked and moved to the right but was unable to avoid running into the side of it.

The Driver

Reginald Hedgecock was driving northbound in the right turn lane of Hollywood Road, also intending to turn right onto Highway 33. He told Ms. Charlton-Minor after the crash that he had seen her in the cycle lane beside him but then forgot about her.

The Driver's Position

Mr. Hedgecock's position was that Ms. Charlton-Miner should not have attempted to proceed straight through the intersection in the cycle lane. She should have moved over to the through lane and continued in the cycle lane after she had ridden across the intersection.

Decision on Liability

Mr. Justice Wilson examines the law with regard to the rights and duties or a cyclist, turning at intersections and careless driving. He disagreed with Mr. Hedgecock and found that Ms. Charlton-Miner was entitled to use the cycle lane. The driver was found to be 100% liable for the collision.

Right Hook Collisions

Drivers should do the following to avoid a right hook collision with a cyclist:

• Signal well in advance of the right turn
• Check your mirrors and shoulder check to prior to turning
• Yield the right of way to cyclists present in the lane or bike lane
• If permitted, make the turn from as close to the curb as is practicable
• Consider that some cyclists may be moving at a significant speed

Learn More

• Read the reasons for judgment - Charlton-Miner v Hedgecock

Share This Article